The Nostalgia Critic loves Christmas and he loves the Ninja Turtles. So, putting both things together should be a match made in Heaven, no? Nope. The first lump of coal in the Critic's stocking is that horrendous Turtle Christmas musical from our childhoods, the memory of which we all managed to suppress...until now. No worries, the Nostalgia Critic will remember it so we don't have to.