Piper starts a band with Jarvis, Bowie, and Knox. When Knox breaks both his arms, they find a replacement drummer in Geneva, who proves to be an incredible natural talent. But when Geneva starts making changes to brighten things up, the other band members follow suit. Soon Piper's goth-inspired band has transformed into a bubble gum pop group. Disappointed that the band would choose Geneva's ideas over hers, Piper quits... until Jarvis makes her see there's such a thing as compromise.