While the survivors gather at the Candlewick, Chloe and Abby help Cal to patch up the sheriff. Shane turns up to taunt the group, but Henry arrives in time to stop him. Jimmy gives Henry some critical papers from JD's pocket which lead Abby to question her own paternity. When Beth disappears, the friends search a tunnel network beneath the inn. Henry and Jimmy need Shane's truck to rescue Abby, but the vehicle is swiped by Trish and Shea. The sheriff disappears from Cal's care; Madison's recovery throws new suspicion on someone close to Abby.