The men in the Sutton household are facing problems with the respective women in their lives. Henry likes Rebecca and anonymously has been writing her romantic, poetic letters, which she loves. She not only loves the letters themselves but also the mystery. But when she mentions that she'd like to find out who her secret admirer is, Pritchard pipes up that the letters are from him. Fuming, Henry decides that he needs to get back at Pritchard, which he manages to do with a little help from Hub. In the natural evolution of Hub and Laura's relationship, she is waiting for him to give her his newly acquired athletics letter, but that is the farthest thing from his mind. Not that he doesn't like Laura in that way or wants to give the letter to anyone else, but he's been preoccupied about what he wants to do with his life, namely joining the priesthood, an idea he has yet to tell to anyone. But with a little advice from Max, Hub decides what to do with respect to Laura at least during this ...