An illusionist comes to the station and tries to show the kids a magic trick, but he messes up because he is afraid that his audience will laugh at him. The illusionist thinks that his magic has been lost, but Stacy reassures him by saying that he will get it back soon. When Mister Conductor appears, Becky thinks that he is a toy. Mister Conductor and the kids explain everything and the illusionist gets his magic back.
The kids enter a drawing contest. Becky does not like the way her picture looks, so she asks Mister Conductor to use his magic to draw her a nicer picture. Schemer steals Billy's ink to draw a self-portrait, but finds out that it is disappearing ink. At the end, Becky learns to appreciate her original drawing and she wins third prize.
The kids are selling lemonade and cookies. However, Schemer and Schemee encourage them to raise the prices and sell low-quality products. When Midge Smoot buys some cookies and finds out how awful they taste, she gets upset with Schemer.
The kids are part of a baseball team and Schemer is their coach, hence they are known as The Schemer Team since Schemer paid for the uniforms. Schemer sends Schemee to sneak on the opposing team, The Snarleyville Slashers.
Mister Conductor sits on the information booth, making an entry in his diary. He views three cows grazing in a farm's field on his way back from Doodle Haven, and asks about the reason a cow's milk being white and not green like the grass they eat. In addition, Mister Conductor asks if fish sleep as he writes the question into his diary. He ends the entry by writing that these are private questions are only intended for the diary, and then vanishes. Schemee uses walkie talkies to sneak on everyone. He also reads Becky's mail and turns the station upside down looking ...
It is Valentine's Day at the station and Mister Conductor is working as a Cupid's assistant. Stacy ends up falling in love with Schemer when she accidentally walks through Mister Conductor's magical cloud of dust.
After a drawing of Mr. Conductor is created, some gold dust is left behind and one of the kids takes the gold dust and puts it on the drawing resulting in mass hysteria involving an evil twin of Mr. Conductor.