There's Something About a Soldier (1943) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Conventional Wartime Film, with little war
tarmcgator25 May 2010
First, I'll confess that I didn't see the first few minutes of THERE'S SOMETHING ABOUT A SOLDIER, because of a timing error with my DVR. (I hope TCM will run it again sometime.) What I did see was a fairly conventional Hollywood wartime confection, though more reminiscent of the "preparedness" films made in 1941 or 1942 than most other Hollywood war movies released in 1943.

There's little if any combat in this film. It's set in a stateside training camp and focuses on a group of non-commissioned officers who are training to become second lieutenants in the Army's antiaircraft units, then part of what was called the Coast Artillery Corps. There is an unusual amount of technical information in the film about the Army's principal antiaircraft guns, for military buffs, as well as scenes of classroom and field training.

The personal story focuses on two of the soldiers: Wally Williams (Tom Neal) -- young, cocky, relatively new to the Army -- and Frank Molloy (Bruce Bennett), an older soldier and a combat veteran of the 1942-43 North Africa campaign. Molloy carries the memory of losing a close friend, Capt. Harkness, in combat, and it just so happens that Carol Harkness (Evelyn Keyes), the dead friend's sister, has gone to work for the Army at Frank's training camp. Carol also catches Wally's eye, and a rivalry over her develops quickly. In the classroom, Wally is a math whiz, but he refuses to help Frank and other officer candidates who are struggling with the numbers. Eventually, Wally comes to appreciate the relationship between Frank and Carol, but goes too far in trying to help Frank pass the course and get his commission. It's a conventional triangle story that had been used many times before and would be employed many times afterward by various filmmakers.

This was a low-budget quickie by Columbia, with a sizable cast but just a few minimal sets. Much of the film was shot, apparently, at Camp Davis, N.C., the Army's principal antiaircraft school at that time; but it's evident that the second-unit location photography was used to provide rear-projection backgrounds for the main actors on a Columbia soundstage. It's not an awful film, but it contains nothing that military movie buffs haven't seen before, save for the focus on antiaircraft guns. Neal is appropriately annoying in his self-centered behavior, and Bennett is suitably stoic (actually, kind of wooden -- he was much better in later films like MILDRED PIERCE and THE TREASURE OF THE SIERRA MADRE). Evelyn Keyes -- probably best-known as Suellen O'Hara in GONE WITH THE WIND -- was a lovely actress and quite credible here. If you look quickly, you also can see the youthful Shelley Winters in her first film, and LEAVE IT TO BEAVER fans will enjoy seeing Hugh Beaumont as a hard-nosed training officer.

All in all, THERE'S SOMETHING ABOUT A SOLDIER is a conventional wartime programmer. Military buffs and completists, as well as fans of the principals, may enjoy it, but all in all, it's not a memorable movie.
13 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
It's essentially a William Haines film set during WWII.
MartinHafer20 May 2017
In the 1920s and early 30s, William Haines made a ton of very formulaic films. In each, he was a very successful and naturally gifted guy...but he also had a huge ego and looked out only for himself. Eventually, he'd end up doing something to disgrace himself and ultimately he'd do something very selfless to show that down deep he really is a stand-up sort of fellow. Well, despite "There's Something About a Soldier" not starring Haines and begin made a decade later, it's essentially the same sort of picture.

The very talented fat-head in this one is Walter 'Wally' Williams (Tom Tryon). He's cocky, brash and only cares about himself. But through the course of the film he learns to be more and more selfless and decent. However, try as he might to help one of his fellow officer candidate school students, Frank (Bruce Bennett*), hates his guts...and he doesn't realize how much Wally has done to try to help him. Ultimately, Wally ends up getting thrown out of the school all while trying to help Frank.

Overall, this is formulaic but very well done. Using second-tier stars, the picture does a good job telling the story as well as instilling the patriotic spirit in the audience.

*Bruce Bennett was never a huge star but his past is interesting. His real name was Herman Brix and he was a silver medalist in the 1928 Olympics! He parlayed this into playing Tarzan and a variety of other roles. But when his career stalled, he changed his name to Bennett and ultimately appeared in about 150 productions!
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
There may be something, but unfortunately, it isn't shown here.
mark.waltz23 July 2019
Warning: Spoilers
This will never be considered the original version of "An Officer and a Gentleman". It has a nice start setting up the two characters played by Tom Neal and Bruce Bennett, quick rivals at officer training school because of Neal's arrogance and Bennett's determination to stick to the books. The truth is, the two characters are like oil and water and they would not get along anywhere under any circumstance. A rivalry for Evelyn Keyes doesn't make the situation any easier.

Hugh Beaumont as the lieutenant in charge of their barracks is a tough, no-nonsense character, a far cry from his sitcom role on "Leave It to Beaver". This works best as a slice of military life drama, showing the educational paths they must follow, how the skills of each of the candidates guide their career futures, and how the strain can make or break an officer candidate. Neal's arrogant character isn't a character you'll easily root for, and his sudden change in attitude doesn't come without some doubt.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed