For the past couple of years, the Hollywood rumor mill has been filled with stories about Henry Cavill
’s management renegotiating his Superman contract with Warner Bros. When Ben Affleck
departed the role of Batman and the DC Extended Universe charged ahead with a wholly new take on the character, it seemed inevitable that Cavill would eventually vacate the role of Superman.
Related: 10 Ways To Fix Superman In The Dceu
But nothing has been confirmed, and Cavill is still technically the Dceu’s Superman, at least for the foreseeable future. So, here are five reasons why Henry Cavill should be replaced as Superman, and five why he should keep the role.